some thoughts on The Silence of the Lambs
Jan. 24th, 2015 07:31 pmGenerally speaking, I think movies made from books are never as good as the original material. The Silence of the Lambs has not joined my short list of exceptions.
This is not to say that it's a bad movie! No, it's a very good movie. It deserved that Oscar. But the book is better.
( Obviously the case had to be streamlined, which was by and large done sensibly... )
But really, Clarice Starling is the heart of the story; it lives and dies with her characterization. I miss seeing her do technical forensic work, and I miss seeing her consciously decide that she's willing to flunk out of Quantico rather than abandon Catherine Martin and the case, but aside from the sexist warping of the basement scene at the end, she makes it largely intact from book to screenplay and Jodie Foster brings her convincingly to life.
So yeah. A good movie. Still not as good as the book, but a very good movie. I'm glad I watched it. :D
-----
(For the record, the two movies that I think are better than their source books are The Princess Bride and Mysterious Skin. There are probably also some movies that are better than their source short stories, but while those face the problem of translating from one medium to another, they don't have the problem of how to tell the same story while chopping at least half of it out.)
This is not to say that it's a bad movie! No, it's a very good movie. It deserved that Oscar. But the book is better.
( Obviously the case had to be streamlined, which was by and large done sensibly... )
But really, Clarice Starling is the heart of the story; it lives and dies with her characterization. I miss seeing her do technical forensic work, and I miss seeing her consciously decide that she's willing to flunk out of Quantico rather than abandon Catherine Martin and the case, but aside from the sexist warping of the basement scene at the end, she makes it largely intact from book to screenplay and Jodie Foster brings her convincingly to life.
So yeah. A good movie. Still not as good as the book, but a very good movie. I'm glad I watched it. :D
-----
(For the record, the two movies that I think are better than their source books are The Princess Bride and Mysterious Skin. There are probably also some movies that are better than their source short stories, but while those face the problem of translating from one medium to another, they don't have the problem of how to tell the same story while chopping at least half of it out.)