edenfalling: stylized black-and-white line art of a sunset over water (Default)
A new AO3 data meme going around, wherein you list your top fic (by number of kudos) for each year.

This is a little tricky for me since I backdate works, but I'm going to start with 2009 since that was the first year AO3 existed. Also the only things I actually posted there in that year were my Yuletide fics, so even though I have backdated-to-2009 words with more kudos, the answer I'm going with is:

2009: Loving Bonds (The Dark Is Rising, only 29 kudos, but 17 comment threads -- note that kudos did not exist at this time)

The next two years get slightly fuzzy, because I still wasn't posting anything to AO3 except challenge responses (aka Remix and Yuletide) for a while and I legit do not remember exactly when I started to post other stuff there, though I think I may have crossposted a few things during this period for idiosyncratic reasons? But it turns out that my most kudosed fic for 2010 was part of Remix Redux and was therefore actually put on AO3 at the time it claims to have been posted there, and only one backdated-to-2011 work has more kudos than one of my 2011 Yuletide fics, so.

2010: What Isn't Broken (Can Still Be Fixed) (Naruto, 1,323 kudos -- even though I think kudos still weren't a thing when this was posted! It remains my most popular fic on the site, actually; the Claw liked that story, for whatever reason)

2011: As You Wish (The Dark Is Rising, 170 kudos -- I am fairly sure kudos had been rolled out by this point?)

2012 is when I started to post all my work to AO3 -- this is because I started writing for Homestuck and ff.net disallows both funky text effects and chat-fics -- so from here on out there's no need to worry about tweaking for some semblance of historical relevance.

2012: Problems and Solutions (All Things in Time) (Chronicles of Narnia/Stargate: SG-1, 576 kudos)

2013: Take Deeper Roots (Chronicles of Narnia/Naruto, 235 kudos)

2014: Giant Robot Mayhem Doesn't Happen in a Day (Homestuck, 434 kudos)

2015: Broken If Revealed (Daredevil, 297 kudos)

2016: The Courting Dance (Chronicles of Narnia, 160 kudos -- this is a chaptered fic started in 2010 (I backdated the earlier chapters, though I don't remember when I actually posted them), but I finished it in 2016 for WIP Big Bang, so whatever)

2017: Maboroshi (Naruto, 246 kudos)

2018: Edmund and Ginny Go to Harfang (Chronicles of Narnia/Harry Potter, 131 kudos -- this is a WIP collection of loosely connected drabbles that I add "chapters" to at random intervals. Actually, it occurs to me that I should poke at my bingo cards to see if something jumps out at me for the next installment...)

2019 so far: The Guardian in Spite of Herself (Naruto, 310 kudos -- another WIP that I should get back to working on, whoops!)
edenfalling: stylized black-and-white line art of a sunset over water (Default)
It's that time of year again. (Well, about a week and a half late, but pssh, details.)

Here are the results from 2018, 2017, 2016, 2015, 2014, 2013 and 2012, for comparison purposes.

I currently have 539 stories posted on AO3, which is 34 more than last year. I think almost all of the new fics were genuinely written during the past year, though I might also have crossposted a few backdated things; I honestly don't remember.

Anyway, here are my top ten works on AO3, by hit count:

1. What Isn't Broken (Can Still Be Fixed) - 29,687 [Naruto, remix]
2. The Way of the Apartment Manager - 7,872 [Naruto, chaptered]
3. Definitions of Romance - 6,914 [Harry Potter]
4. With a Vengeance - 6,588 [Naruto]
5. I Must Increase My Bust - 6,289 [Homestuck]
6. More Sins than Condemnation - 6,079 [Naruto]
7. Trollstuck: Make Her Pay - 5,883 [Homestuck, chaptered, WIP]
8. Problems and Solutions (All Things in Time) - 5,867 [Chronicles of Narnia/Stargate: SG-1, remix]
9. Four by Four - 5,096 [Homestuck, chaptered, WIP]
10. The Guardian in Spite of Herself - 4,369 [Naruto, chaptered, WIP]

As in previous years, this list is slow to change. There's been a bit of internal rearrangement, "Definitions of Romance" jumped from #11 (and thus not on last year's list) to #3, and "Guardian" appeared at #10 -- probably because I added a new chapter in early 2019 -- but that's about it. :)

Moving on!

Here are my top ten stories by number of kudos )

A more general trend is my Naruto fics sliding back up the rankings relative to my Homestuck fics. This is probably because, as mentioned above, I posted a new chapter of "Guardian" in early 2019 and there's been some spillover to my other work in that fandom; also, Homestuck fandom in general was slowing down until the epilogues dropped just a couple weeks ago.

And now I'm going to go read a book. :)
edenfalling: stylized black-and-white line art of a sunset over water (Default)
As of this morning, What Isn't Broken (Can Still Be Fixed) has 1,000 kudos on AO3.

...

I'm a middle ground writer, I think -- I'm never going to get the numbers of a BNF writing juggernaut ships in a juggernaut fandom, but I seem to have a moderately solid readership for various things. But by "moderately solid," I mean I can usually expect double-digits in kudos on my fics. Triple digits are relatively rare, and this is the first time a fic of mine has reached quadruple digit kudos.

I don't expect it to happen again, but it's a nice milestone nonetheless. :)
edenfalling: stylized black-and-white line art of a sunset over water (Default)
It's that time of year again. :)

Here are the results from 2017, 2016, 2015, 2014, 2013 and 2012, for comparison purposes.

I currently have 505 stories posted on AO3, which is 26 more than last year. I think almost all of the new fics were genuinely written during the past year, though I might also have crossposted a few backdated things; I honestly don't remember.

Anyway, here are my top ten works on AO3, by hit count:

1. What Isn't Broken (Can Still Be Fixed) - 24,746 [Naruto, remix]
2. I Must Increase My Bust - 5,815 [Homestuck]
3. Trollstuck: Make Her Pay - 5,723 [Homestuck, chaptered, WIP]
4. With a Vengeance - 5,618 [Naruto]
5. The Way of the Apartment Manager - 5,292 [Naruto, chaptered]
6. More Sins than Condemnation - 5,279 [Naruto]
7. Problems and Solutions (All Things in Time) - 4,931 [Chronicles of Narnia/Stargate: SG-1, remix]
8. Four by Four - 4,833 [Homestuck, chaptered, WIP]
9. Dreamers of the Day - 4,376 [Inception]
10. Of Stone and of Sky - 4,369 [Homestuck, Ladystuck]

This is largely the same as last year, barring a few internal rearrangements -- most notably "The Way of the Apartment Manager" jumping from #10 to #5. I am pleased that my most popular story on other sites is finally picking up steam over here, too, despite its age and backdating. :D (Side note: "Definitions of Romance," another old and backdated fic, has moved to #11 on my hit count list, which is slowly bringing it into line with its performance on other sites.)

"What Isn't Broken" continues to absolutely crush everything else I've ever written, at least on this particular site. I am still unsure why, but hey, if people like it I'm not going to complain. *wry* It also drags its two companion ficlets ("With a Vengeance" and "More Sins than Condemnation") up the rankings... at least in terms of hit count. Their kudos count is more variable.

Anyway, moving on!

Here are my top ten stories by number of kudos )

The bookmark list continues to share a lot of commonalities with the hit and kudos lists (particularly if you go by the top twenty rather than just the top ten), and the comment list continues to be noticeably different from those three, though this year that discrepancy finally seems to owe as much to comments on multi-chapter fics as to comments on fic exchange works.
edenfalling: stylized black-and-white line art of a sunset over water (Default)
(via [tumblr.com profile] venusmelody)

I actually did this a year ago, but what the heck, let's see if the answers have changed much since then. For reference, I currently have 486 fics on AO3.

Go to your AO3 works page, expand all the filters, and answer the following questions!

1. What's your first and second most common work ratings? Any surprises?

General Audiences (359) / Teen And Up Audiences (97) / Not Rated (14) / Mature (10) / Explicit (6)

No surprises here! I write a lot of gen, and I am skeptical of movie-style ratings' applicability to prose (plus I dislike issuing implicit judgments about what material is ~appropriate~ for people I know nothing about), so I mostly rate things in a spirit of "read the tags and decide for yourself" ('General Audiences'), with an occasional detour into "well, I guess this is a little heavier; maybe I should up the rating so people who care about ratings don't yell at me even though I have accurately tagged for the heavy stuff so what is even the point" ('Teen And Up Audiences').

I love tags. Tags are specific and therefore useful! Ratings, not so much.

The six 'Explicit' stories include actual porn, and the 'Mature' ones include sex that isn't quite porn and/or some heavy stuff. (Mostly sex, though. People get weird about sex in ways they don't tend to get weird about violence, so I usually deploy those ratings based on the presence of sex and stuff that's tangential to sex and stick to tags for everything else.) The 'Not Rated' stories are all from the same Angel Sanctuary fic series, which I CAN'T rate usefully for reasons that are probably obvious if you have any familiarity with the source manga.

(I used to have other unrated stories, but I decided this past year that I wanted to reserve that category for the Angel Sanctuary fics and slapped the others with either 'General Audiences' or 'Teen And Up' based on the ~highly scientific~ system of how I felt when I did a quick-skim reread of each story. *wry*)

cut for length )

And that is that. :)
edenfalling: stylized black-and-white line art of a sunset over water (Default)
It's that time of year again. :)

Here are the results from 2016, 2015, 2014, 2013 and 2012, for comparison purposes.

I currently have 479 stories posted on AO3, which is 44 more than last year. The 'new' fics are a combination of backdated crossposts and things that were genuinely written within the past year.

Anyway, here are my top ten stories on AO3, by hit count:

1. What Isn't Broken (Can Still Be Fixed) - 20,463 [Naruto, remix]
2. Trollstuck: Make Her Pay - 5,540 [Homestuck, chaptered, WIP]
3. I Must Increase My Bust - 5,104 [Homestuck]
4. With a Vengeance - 4,766 [Naruto]
5. More Sins than Condemnation - 4,522 [Naruto]
6. Four by Four - 4,482 [Homestuck, chaptered, WIP]
7. Of Stone and of Sky - 4,257 [Homestuck, Ladystuck]
8. Dreamers of the Day - 4,140 [Inception]
9. Problems and Solutions (All Things in Time) - 4,116 [Chronicles of Narnia/Stargate: SG-1, remix]
10. The Way of the Apartment Manager - 3,485 [Naruto, chaptered]

This is largely the same as last year, barring a few internal rearrangements and "The Way of the Apartment Manager" kicking "Weregild" off the list. I am pleased that my most popular story on other sites is finally picking up steam over here, too, despite its age and backdating. :)

"What Isn't Broken" continues to absolutely crush everything else I've ever written, at least on this particular site. I am still unsure why, but hey, if people like it I'm not going to complain. *wry* It also drags its two companion ficlets ("With a Vengeance" and "More Sins than Condemnation") up the rankings... at least in terms of hit count. Their kudos count is more variable.

Anyway, moving on!

Here are my top ten stories by number of kudos )

The bookmark list continues to share a lot of commonalities with the hit and kudos lists (particularly if you go by the top twenty rather than just the top ten), and the comment list continues to be noticeably different from those three, largely thanks to Yuletide and the Narnia Fic Exchange. :)
edenfalling: stylized black-and-white line art of a sunset over water (Default)
I was tagged by [tumblr.com profile] klaineharmony:

Go to your works page, expand all the filters, and answer the following questions!

I currently have 445 works on AO3. This tally is therefore missing some stuff I haven't yet crossposted (most notably all my Angel Sanctuary fic) and some things (mostly fragments) that will never exist away from my journal. Additionally, AO3 does not scrape one's entire catalogue once it gets past a certain size -- the sidebar is built from only the first X number of pages (ten? twenty? I don't know the details) -- so these meme results are not completely accurate (most easily demonstrable when it comes to the number of fics in certain categories). That said...

What are your first and second most common work ratings? Any surprises?

General Audiences (335)
Teen And Up Audiences (83)

This does not surprise me. I don't write a lot of porn, and I don't see much point in the Teen And Up rating -- probably because I don't see much point in fic ratings in general. Relatively specific content notes are useful, but ratings are as far from specific as you can get. Seriously, what does an estimated 'appropriate audience' even MEAN? And how do you know whether any given reader will agree with your decision?

I'm also reluctant to issue judgments on who should be reading what content at what age, since I am quite sure that various things I read as a child -- and by 'child' I mean 8-12 years old -- would make moral guardians scream in horror, yet I sailed through unharmed. So I default toward 'whatever, just read it' and only occasionally slap a 'hey, this might be a little heavier' note onto something when my understanding of the public consensus on various issues suggests people might get ticked off at seeing them in the 'General Audiences' category.

(I am even less likely to use 'Mature' or 'Explicit,' because see above in re: not writing much porn. I do occasionally go with 'Not Rated' because there are a few things where I have no clue what the public consensus rating would be and figure it's better to let individual readers decide for themselves.)

cut for length )

Tag 5 people!

I am terrible at tagging. Play if you want to!
edenfalling: stylized black-and-white line art of a sunset over water (Default)
Let's bring this one around again. :) Here are the results from 2015, 2014, 2013 and 2012, for comparison purposes.

I currently have 435 stories posted on AO3, which is about 80 more than last year. I still have not cross-posted all my back-catalogue, for various and sundry reasons, so most of those 'new' fics were genuinely written within the past year.

With that said, here are my top ten stories on AO3, by hit count:

1. What Isn't Broken (Can Still Be Fixed) - 16,527 [Naruto, remix]
2. Trollstuck: Make Her Pay - 5,325 [Homestuck, chaptered, WIP]
3. I Must Increase My Bust - 4,438 [Homestuck]
4. Of Stone and of Sky - 4,164 [Homestuck, Ladystuck]
5. Four by Four - 4,045 [Homestuck, chaptered, WIP]
6. With a Vengeance - 3,940 [Naruto]
7. Dreamers of the Day - 3,872 [Inception]
8. More Sins than Condemnation - 3,766 [Naruto]
9. Problems and Solutions (All Things in Time) - 3,424 [Chronicles of Narnia/Stargate: SG-1, remix]
10. Weregild - 3,170 [Inception/Anita Blake, chaptered, WIP]

This is largely the same as last year, barring a few internal rearrangements and "Problems and Solutions" kicking "A History of Handcrafts" down to #11 and therefore off the list. (I believe "Problems and Solutions" was #12 by hit count last year.)

"What Isn't Broken" continues to absolutely crush everything else I've ever written, at least on this particular site. I am not entirely sure why. I mean, it's a good story! But I think several of my other stories are just as good, if not better. Perhaps it's simply that AO3 leans toward slash and that fic is both one of my actual attempts at slash romance and a sort of retroactive 'fix-it' for the way Naruto canon ended.

(By way of comparison, over on ff.net "What Isn't Broken" is only at #12 [19,472], despite having "With a Vengeance" and "More Sins Than Condemnation" tacked on as 'chapters' to increase its hit count. It is completely flattened by "The Way of the Apartment Manager" [448,511], "The Guardian in Spite of Herself" [256,698], "An Ounce of Prevention" [143,109], and "Lemonade" [114,282].)

Anyway, moving on!

Here are my top ten stories by number of kudos )

The bookmark list continues to share a lot of commonalities with the hit and kudos lists (particularly if you go by the top twenty rather than just the top ten), and the comment list continues to be noticeably different from those three, largely thanks to Yuletide and the Narnia Fic Exchange. :)
edenfalling: stylized black-and-white line art of a sunset over water (Default)
Oh hey, looks like this one is going around again. :-)

I currently have 387 works archived on AO3. Pick a number from 1 (the most recent) to 387 (the first thing I posted*), and I'll tell you three things I currently like about it!

*Technically this is not true, because backdating, but it is the oldest work which is the relevant point.

-----

#187: "Blueprints" [Inception]

#259 and #144: "What Isn't Broken (Can Still Be Fixed)" [Naruto] and "Narutostuck: The Mother of Necessity" [Homestuck/Naruto fusion]

#227 and #27: "Bluebell" [fairy-tale retelling] and "Mycophilia" [Homestuck]

#167: "Dreams From My Mother" [Black Jewels]

#184: "Lives by Mending" [Darkangel Trilogy]

#66: "Small Favors" [Naruto, specifically the 'Apartment Manager' AU]

#221: "Everything Ends" [Doctor Who with elements from Ender's Game]

#198: "Sparkly Rainbow Blood" [Homestuck]
edenfalling: stylized black-and-white line art of a sunset over water (Default)
Oh right, it's that time of year again. :-) Here are the results from 2014, 2013 and 2012, for comparison purposes.

I currently have 359 stories posted on AO3, which is over twice as many as last year, about six times as many as in 2013, and about ten times as many as in 2012. As you can see, I finally got around to cross-posting a lot of my back-catalog. (I still haven't put up the Angel Sanctuary fics, nor the longer chaptered WIPs, but hey. Progress is progress!) I backdate all those old stories, so their hit and kudos counts remain relatively low.

With that said, here are my top ten stories on AO3, by hit count:

1. What Isn't Broken (Can Still Be Fixed) - 12,707 [Naruto, remix]
2. Trollstuck - 4,910 [Homestuck, chaptered, WIP]
3. Of Stone and of Sky - 3,923 [Homestuck, Ladystuck]
4. I Must Increase My Bust - 3,830 [Homestuck]
5. Four by Four - 3,507 [Homestuck, chaptered, WIP]
6. Dreamers of the Day - 3,438 [Inception]
7. With a Vengeance - 3,026 [Naruto]
8. Weregild - 3,021 [Inception/Anita Blake, chaptered, WIP]
9. More Sins than Condemnation - 2,919 [Naruto]
10. A History of Handcrafts (Because a Sweater Equals Love) - 2,848 [Star Trek: AOS, remix]

This is noticeably different from last year. "Of Stone and of Sky," posted January 2014, climbed all the way to number 3! (I am still not sure what's going on there.) "Four by Four" moved up because I posted a third chapter in December, and the two sidefics to "What Isn't Broken" rode their parent story's coattails back up the rankings, shoving a couple Homestuck fics down and off the list.

Meanwhile, "What Isn't Broken" has become even more disproportionately better-read than all my other stories on AO3. I've been tracking it with sort of bemused curiosity, and for the record, it passed 10,000 hits last October, and 12,000 hits on my birthday in February, which was a nice but trivial additional gift. *wry* It also dominates the kudos and bookmark lists.

On that note, here are my top ten stories by number of kudos )

I'm not going to do lists by number of bookmarks or comment threads, but I will say for the record that the bookmark list is pretty similar to the two lists I did write out in full. (The major difference there is the inclusion of The Way of the Apartment Manager at number 4, though backdating means that fic still languishes low on the hit count and kudos lists.) The comment list, on the other hand, pulls up some very different stories. That is entirely because of the Yuletide effect -- Yuletide being a fest with a culture of active commenting, perhaps as a holdover from its pre-kudos-button years, or perhaps because tiny fandoms of the heart inspire greater enthusiasm and a wish to communicate with others who also love your particular tiny and obscure sources of joy.

Profile

edenfalling: stylized black-and-white line art of a sunset over water (Default)
Elizabeth Culmer

April 2025

S M T W T F S
  12345
678910 1112
1314151617 1819
20212223242526
27282930   

Tags

Expand Cut Tags

No cut tags